European Parliament fails to address problems with self- regulation of alcohol marketing
21st February 2013. The Committee on Culture and Education (CULT) in the European Parliament has voted on the report examining the implementation of the Audiovisual Media Services Directive (AVMSD).
An own initiative report (2012/21329INI) by -Piotr Borys (PL, EPP).
Some MEPs had submitted amendments addressing the ineffectiveness of self- regulatory codes in relation to alcohol marketing, especially regarding protection of minors (Amendments 69, 99, 100). Unfortunately, these amendments were all rejected in the CULT Committee vote.
Currently, most of marketing regulation in the EU is done through voluntary codes. Article 4 (7) of AVMSD encourages self and co-regulation, however these have a number of substantial shortcomings and fail to effectively protect minors from exposure to alcohol marketing.
For instance in the AVMSD Directive Article 9 (e) states that: audiovisual commercial communication for alcoholic beverages shall not be aimed specifically at minors and shall not encourage immoderate consumption of such beverages. In practice this provision provides a loophole for advertisers, who create marketing that appeals to both young people as well as adults.
Another shortcoming is that the majority self-regulatory codes propose a 30% or 25% threshold. This threshold prohibits alcohol advertising if the audience consists of more than 25% or 30% of minors. In practice these thresholds do not seem to be able to protect minors from being shielded from alcohol adverts. For example a football match might have only 6% of audience aged 13-15 but the exposure in absolute numbers of young people watching is significant.
In 2009, the Science Group of the European Alcohol and Health Forum produced a report which reviewed a number of studies on the impact of marketing on the volume and patterns of drinking. The report concluded that alcohol marketing increases the likelihood that young people will start to drink alcohol, and that among those who have started to drink, marketing increases the their drinking levels in terms of both amount and frequency. 43% among 15-16 year old European students reported heavy binge drinking during the past 30 days and alcohol is the single biggest cause of death among young men of age 16 to 24 (ESPAD, 2011)
Eurocare is firmly convinced that European provisions in the area of Audiovisual Media Services should reflect these issues and encourage better regulation of alcohol marketing which reaches minors.